Here's what I ask myself every time I finish reading one of your essays:
Is
it a story?
Does it have a clear
beginning, middle, and end (not necessarily in that order)?
Does it deepen the reader’s
understanding of the subject?
Is
it well organized?
Do the events come in the
best order?
Are the
transitions between ideas smooth and logical?
Is the opening
precise, specific, and engaging? Is it the intro that only this author can
write?
Are paragraphs
fully developed (with appropriate details or adequate examples)?
Does the closing effectively
emphasize, elaborate, or illuminate the main ideas of the story?
Is
the language interesting?
Does the writer make
precise, powerful diction choices?
Does the writer
employ rhetorical strategies that engage the reader and emphasize the purpose?
Are appeals to
ethos, pathos, and logos balance, effective, and appropriate for audience and
purpose?
Does the writer
include a sufficient amount of showing?
Does the writer take risks?
Does
this look like a college paper?
Does it follow MLA format?
Does it display
a college-level control of spelling, grammar, and punctuation?
Did the writer meet the
requirements of the assignment, including the nit-picky details?