Sunday, May 17, 2015

The Justice Test

Below, you will find 22 hypothetical situations. Your job is to think about them and figure if each one is just or unjust. Once you know whether it is just or unjust, you need to figure out why. If you can explain why, you will have one small piece of your personal definition of justice nailed down.

As we discovered in class, it's okay if your personal definition of justice isn't 100% consistent. It's also okay to realize that something is unjust and still do it anyway. Most people, if not all, are willing to tolerate some amount of injustice in our lives.

1.     Our school’s dress code (and the enforcement thereof).
2.     Illegally downloading copyrighted music.
3.     Throwing loud, raucous parties that last late into the night.
4.     Establishing 21 as the legal age to purchase and consume alcohol.
5.     Expecting all students – regardless of race, social class, gender, and intellectual ability – to pass the same standardized test.
6.     Censorship of school newspapers and yearbooks.
7.     Censorship of violent and pornographic entertainment.
8.     Censorship of hate speech.
9.     Protecting the environment in the United States at the cost of jobs by preventing practices such as oil drilling, hydrolic fracking, and logging.
10.  Protecting the environment in the United States by using energy efficient devices such as electric cars and solar panels.
11.  Exporting the environmental damage caused by the production of car batteries and solar panels to third world countries.
12.  Eating babies.
13.  Eating bacon.
14.  Factory farming meat as opposed to raising free range livestock for meat.
15.  Publishing all government documents – including tax codes, warning signs, and driver’s exams – in English only.
16.  Providing the highest quality medical care only to those who can afford to pay for it.
17.  Providing health care to all citizens, which may reduce access to essential care for some.
18.  Paying professional athletes millions of dollars.
19.  Detonating a suicide bomb on a crowded city bus.
20.  Dropping bombs from military jets.
21.  Dropping bombs from a drone.

22.  Torturing a person to gain important military information.

No comments:

Post a Comment